Debt Consolidation vs Personal Loan: Which is Better for You?
Complete comparison to help you choose the right option and save thousands on interest.
Quick Answer
Use Debt Consolidation when: You have 3+ high-interest debts, struggling with multiple payments
Use Personal Loan when: You need new funds for a specific purpose (not paying off existing debts)
Key Differences Explained
| Feature | Debt Consolidation | Personal Loan |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Pay off existing debts | Get new funds for any use |
| How it works | Combine multiple debts into one | Receive lump sum cash |
| Interest Rate | Usually lower (6-10%) | Varies (4.88-18%) |
| Best for | Multiple high-interest debts | Single new expense |
When Debt Consolidation is Better
✓ Choose Debt Consolidation if you:
- • Have 3+ different loans or credit cards
- • Paying high interest (15%+ average)
- • Struggling to track multiple payment dates
- • Want to simplify finances into one payment
- • Can qualify for lower interest rate
Real Example:
Sarah's Situation:
• Credit Card A: RM15,000 @ 18% (RM450/mo)
• Credit Card B: RM10,000 @ 17% (RM300/mo)
• Personal Loan: RM20,000 @ 12% (RM600/mo)
Total: RM1,350/month to 3 lenders
After consolidation:
• One loan: RM45,000 @ 8% = RM915/month
Saves RM435/month + RM15,660 over 5 years!
When Personal Loan is Better
✓ Choose Personal Loan if you:
- • Need cash for a new expense (renovation, wedding, etc.)
- • Have only 1-2 existing debts
- • Current debts already have low rates
- • Want flexibility in how to use the money
- • Don't have multiple debt problems
Real Example:
Ahmad's Situation:
Needs RM30,000 for home renovation. Has only one car loan at 6% which is manageable. A personal loan at 7-8% makes sense - he gets the cash he needs without touching his existing low-rate car loan.
Cost Comparison Calculator
Scenario: RM60,000 Total Debt
Option A: Keep Separate Loans
3 loans averaging 15% interest
RM2,100/month
5-year total: RM126,000
Interest paid: RM66,000
Option B: Debt Consolidation
1 loan at 8% interest
RM1,215/month
5-year total: RM72,900
Interest paid: RM12,900
💰 Consolidation Saves: RM53,100!
Plus RM885 lower monthly payment
Common Mistakes to Avoid
❌ Mistake #1: Consolidating Low-Interest Debt
Don't consolidate a 5% car loan into a 10% consolidation loan. Only consolidate debts with higher rates than your new loan.
❌ Mistake #2: Getting Personal Loan to Pay Debts (Wrong Way)
If you take a personal loan and receive cash to your account, you might spend it instead of paying debts. Use proper debt consolidation where lender pays creditors directly.
❌ Mistake #3: Accumulating New Debt After Consolidation
After consolidating credit cards, don't use them again! Close them or keep at zero balance, otherwise you'll have old debt + new debt.
Not Sure Which Option is Right for You?
Get personalized recommendation based on your situation
Get Free Consultation - Apply Now📚 Related Articles
Debt Consolidation Malaysia 2025: Complete Guide to Combining Loans
Complete guide to debt consolidation in Malaysia. Learn how to combine multiple loans, reduce monthly payments, save on interest, and become debt-free faster.
Debt Consolidation Guide Malaysia 2025: Simplify Your Finances
Complete guide to debt consolidation in Malaysia. Learn how to combine multiple loans into one, reduce monthly payments, and save thousands on interest.
How to Get Personal Loan in Malaysia 2025: Complete Step-by-Step Guide
Complete guide on how to get personal loan approved in Malaysia. Learn eligibility, documents, application process, tips to improve approval chances. Licensed lender guide.